Monday, February 12, 2007

Doesn't this seem all too familiar???



What I think is that they are so easily influenced, that they can so easily think up excuses for the plainly inexcusable, and that they are so adept at maneuvers and manipulation that many would be able to think their way around whatever is said to them.For example, if I told them (as I could of my old church organization), "Your church is based upon the biblical understandings of uneducated persons," they would answer, "Thank God, He can use the base things, the rejected persons, the unwise to do His work, while the educated shake their heads in wonder, having no personal knowledge or understanding."If I told them (as I could of my old church organization), "Many in your church have abused others in the name of God," they would answer, "Yes, the church is full of humans, and humans make mistakes."If I told them (as I could of my old church organization), "Two pastors I had in your church touched me inappropriately," they would answer, "That is not believeable, because if it had happened, you would have said something when it happened, but you didn't."If I told them (as I could of my old church organization), "I was told in your church that if I left your church, I and my family would fail spiritually, personally, and financially, but in fact, we are better off now than we were while in your church," they would answer, "It's not over yet. God is not mocked. Whatsoever you sow, that will you reap."If I told them (as I could of my old church organization), "I had a pastor who stood in the pulpit and bragged about his dirty business dealings, and we lost 95% of the youth grooup because of that and because of his treatment of the youth pastor, who tried to explain," they would answer, "Touch not mine annointed. Even if he did, he was placed in that position by God, and you should have submitted to him."Seriously, I think that many (but certainly not all!) in these organizations have


*completely calloused consciences
*absolute narcissism
*complete lack of empathy which they have learned to fake in order to manage socially


---A poster from ex-Pentecostal Forums discussing the mechanics of spiritual abuse in certain charismatic-Pentecostal groups

Sunday, February 11, 2007

A comparison and contrast of a COG7 and ACOG church worship



Bloggist's note:


I can remember in my talks to Church of God (Seventh Day) Confrence President Whaid Rose in his visit to Toronto in the spring of 2000, he concluded that worship in the historic Worldwide Church of God was stoic. WCG National Director Gary Moore agreed with that assesment probably a couple years back in his visit to the Toronto West church.


---Felix Taylor, Jr. Post WCG Life and Theology


"Of the 114 special songs by Dwight Armstrong appearing in the 1974 Hymnal, how many do you think contain the name Christ or Jesus? Do you think most of them, say, about 100? Surely at least half, say 57? Would you be surprised to learn that of all 114 songs, not one contains the name of our Savior."This is 180 degrees from the modern Church of God Seventh Day in some areas where the local CoG7 has its own band and play quite a lot of music in its "Praise Worship" Services. The songs are modern and Evangelical. The words are projected on a large screen that mostly everyone can read. The songs praise Jesus quite a lot as Savior -- by name -- as the CoG7 views themselves as the Bride of Christ honoring her Husband."


Apparently the differences are great


The congregation is warm and non judgmental. People come dressed informally, although you can wear a suit if you wish. There is no pressure. The people are very caring. The minister is not the Sabbath Gestapo in the CoG7. There are a lot more young children and there are many younger families with the parents in their 20s and 30s. Quite a few people never attended church anywhere else before.There are, amazingly enough, altar calls. Tithes and offerings, though not demanded are collected as part of the praise service.Instead of a duty or burden, the Sabbath is considered a gift wherein everyone can leave the cares of the past week behind and concentrate on praising Jesus and worshiping God the Father. There is much more emotional content to the extent that the xcgs seem sterile by comparison.There is even an optional Fall Festival kept at the traditional time.The CoG7 is community based and the ministers of the CoG7 have a rapport with the Sunday keeping Protestant ministers and talk with them frequently. The CoG7 ministers have actual training in credentialed prominent Bible Colleges. One minister did his thesis on William Miller and has family ties to Dugger and Dodd. Some have taken extensive training in the Dead Sea Scrolls.While it may seem odd, with the modern evangelical music, the CoG7 believes in keeping the Commandments, clean and unclean meats but consider themselves New Covenant, devoid of legalism. The idea is to love God and keep the Commandments because they are a gift and because they want to show love to Jesus, not out of duty.The Bible Advocate is one of the most respected religious publications with around 150 years of history. Let us see any other xcg last that long and have a stable congregation of 10,000 strong a century from now.Indeed, the CoG7 from which Herbert Armstrong rebelled because they didn't accept British Israelism from him, is quite a world apart from the xcgs, musically and otherwise.
---excerpts from comments Gavin Rumney's blog discussing the worship styles in the historic WCG

Intelligent Quote of the Day: XCG ministers and Real Jobs

It takes eight long years of study to become a Catholic priest. Almost as long as to become an M.D. And even after all that intense training we still see a few quacks and pedophiles slip thru the process.My question for people like Mark Armstrong is, just what kind of training does he have? Four years at the unaccredited Embarrassing College? Is that it!? And he is now fit to council with people having personal problems or dispense advice from the pulpit?Excuse me, but if a psychologist tried this with no more training than the Armstrongs of the world have, the authorities would close his practice and put him in jail for fraud. It's just too bad that so-called "ministers" aren't held equally accountable. People might as well go to their local palm reader for advice or call Madame Cleo as they would these ACOGs. And it's a lot cheaper too!
---The controversial WCG Alumni message board member "Stingerski'' on XCG minister's poor credentials compared to other professions that demand higher standards and training.

Sunday, February 04, 2007

WCG history made!



Despite my criticisms of both the historical and evangelical Worldwide Church of God, I will say that it has come a long way baby! You gotta give credit to what was a woman-hating organization (and I really believe the historic WCG and it's Armstrongist split-offs hate with a passion, the female sex, especially when the female sex becomes an adult---she is evil, the beauty of her body is especially wicked, women according to Armstrongism is a utility, all aesethetic aspects of a woman should never come into mind!) to an organization that respects women as an equal to a man in the eyes of God. The evangelical WCG went so far of doing a study paper on the issue of ordaining women to the ministry and has very recently ordained a woman into the ministry. The first woman to be ordained in the WCG to ministry is Debby Bailey of Kentucky. Where do I stand on this? I have taken a "moderate complementary" position on this issue. In other words, I have no hang-ups on women doing openening and closing prayer, even doing the occassional sermons and other active involements in the church but I was reluctant to have a woman as a "senior pastor" of a congregation or a "denominational leader" (whether WCG, Lutheran, Baptist, whatever). I believe God had a role for the men in the particular positions. Some friends from the place I attend services Good News Fellowship have contested my "moderate complementarianism" saying, "If you (Felix) can allow a woman to preach and teach, how come you cannot give the woman the recognition by ordaining them." Good question and I do not know all the answers. This is what I know, that the church, which is the invisible body of Christ, are a kingdom of priests---or in other words a preisthood of believers. We, the church are all ministers. When we believe the gospel, respond to it, we are empowered for ministry. It is not a option which you pick and choose what you eat from a menu, it is obligatory. God has created in us special abilities and talents, we should use them to our potential to glorify him. It doesn't matter what race, sex, ability or disability---believers are called to ministry regardless. I guess the issue is about "ordained ministry" is it the same as anyother ministry in the Christian church ---or something different. Obviously, the ultra-conservative splinters will take offence at the recent ordination believing that the WCG is truly apostate and going to The Lake of Fire. Some who have left WCG/XCG are quite happy about this, some have serious reservations and there are some who have left Armstrongism but who are very conservative Protestants believe that the WCG has committed heresy even if it is a minor heresy (which they mean it is non-salvational) it is harmful in some way. Anyway, I believe the Worldwide Church of God should have focused on more practical and pressing issues of dealing with accountability and dismantling the imperial power of pastor general, which if I had my way the office of the Pastor General would have resembled the office of the Archbishop of Canterburry as opposed to the Pope. If it is truly God's will and purpose for Mrs. Bailey to be in "ordained" ministry, I wish her well in her new office but my sympathies extend for her because the evangelical WCG is still an organization with sharks.


Read all about Mrs. Debby Bailey and her ordaination here at http://www.wcg.org/weekly/default.htm

Friday, February 02, 2007

Not-so-nice words from Ronald Kelly









"YOUR JOB IS NOT TO THINK!!!"

---Ronald Kelly, 1974

In my stay in the WCG, I really had a very "high" opinion of WCG Evangelist Ronald D. Kelly. I even admired his "Johnny Appleseed" beard which in the late 1980's he finally disposed of. I first heard him speak at the Feast of Tabernacles at Niagara in 1983 when I was 13 and met him personally when he visited my hometown of Toronto in 1987. Little I knew Ronald Kelly, had a dark side of the force lurking in him. Worldwide Church of God Almuni message board participant PasedenaGuy 10 presents a clip from an former WCG member's book about Ronald Kelly's tactics during the infamous (or famous---take your pick!) rebellion back in 1974.
---Felix Taylor, Post WCG Life and Theology

Laschek tells the story of the upheavals in the WCG during the 1974 ‘crisis’ where over 2,000 members left because of all the lies and deceit going on by the ministry.
On February 25 was the “Monday Massacre.” Garner Ted Armstrong had flown in from headquarters in Pasadena to end confusion and marshal the forces of righteousness. On the twenty-third he had delivered a blistering sermon at Sabbath services, inflaming the faithful with fresh distrust and, in some cases, hatred for the dissidents. IT was an inspired performance by a talented orator. At the end, several hundred people spontaneously leaped to their feet, cheering and waving. I had a vision of Nuremberg, 1935, and was actually frightened. I counted six of us who didn’t cheer.On the twenty-fifth, Garner Ted convened a minister’s conference at AC, and, after a forty-minute opening prayer, which saw him break into sobs, he harangued and intimidated the forty or so assembled church leaders for seven hours. Several entered the meeting with misgivings about the organization, but by the times it was over, only four still stood their ground, resisting the demand for total loyalty. They were fired from the ministry and disfellowshipped.The next day it was the student body’s turn to be purified. Kelly and an associate delivered wild-eyed diatribes calling on us to “purge out those who are not wiling to change!” Everyone knew who he meant; but of course it was the dissidents who had actually changed.) We were told there was a “morass of rebellion” and that the situation was “insane.” The Devil was attempting to divide and conquer God’s church, and the rebels were eon his side, partaking of evil. To cap it off, we were reminded, “there are things we shouldn’t even think; let alone say.”Next day the student body was assembled, and Kelly announced that twenty students had been fired from their campus jobs because they had contact with disfellowshipped persons. The kicker was that he wouldn’t release the names of those who were “terminated.” You had to guess if you were among the causalities, and, therefore, further incriminate yourself by asking for official confirmation.The next day Kelly kicked my friend Pam out of AC. She had been on the termination list and had gone to Kelly’s office to discuss her firing. She wondered why her job had been affected by a visit to a former member. Kelly replied that the salaries were paid via the donations of church members, so it was a betrayal of the brethren to use their money to pay dissidents. It would have been an appropriate moment to mention how the brethren’s money had been used top buy planes, limos, jewelry, and other extravagances for the WCG hierarchy, but Pam merely said, “I don’t think going to see a former minister should have anything to do with my job.”“Your job isn’t to think, “ Kelly replied irritably. “You aren’t paid to think.”“Oh, that’s right,” Pam countered, “Christians aren’t supposed to think.”Kelly began to shout. He yelled, “That’s enough!” He didn’t want to hear any more. He told Pam she was expelled from AC, and, right on the spot, he instructed his secretary to file the necessary papers. As Pam left his office, he slammed the door behind her.The “heretical underground” had grown cynical as the conflict in the WCG unfolded and we howled with mischievous delight when we discovered that Kelly had a bidet installed in the bathroom of his house. Some began to refer to him as “Clean Ass Kelly,” and mused that since so many true believers were “brownnosers,” Kelly’s posterior must be scrupulously maintained in a pristine condition.

Labels:

Links